• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

PJ's Steak & Hoagie Shack: Authentic Cheesesteaks & Hearty Hoagies in New Holland, PA

PJ’s Steak & Hoagie Shack in New Holland, PA, is a beloved local spot known for its outstanding cheesesteaks and generous hoagies. The bread is exceptional—fresh and perfectly toasted—complementing flavorful, tender steak and rich cheeses. Their large hoagies, like the Italian and chicken cordon bleu, offer hearty portions and customizable toppings, satisfying diverse tastes. Paired with crispy fries and flavorful sauces, the meals feel thoughtfully crafted and comforting. Friendly service adds to the inviting atmosphere, making it a place to return to. Whether dining in or picking up, PJ’s delivers classic, crave-worthy sandwiches that truly celebrate Pennsylvania’s sandwich heritage.

PJ's Steak & Hoagie Shack at a glance

  • Address 114 E Main St, New Holland, PA 17557, United States
  • Phone +1 717-351-4949
  • Restaurant type Sandwich shop , Cheesesteak restaurant , Pizza takeaway .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

PJ's Steak & Hoagie Shack: Reviews & Ratings

ashh
5

Pretty sure they are closed but they had the best cheesesteaks here!! The plain ones were really good and their sauce with onions was really really good!! They also had amazing fries and I wish I could be back for more!!!

T Thomas
5

We stopped in here for food and decided to split a large chicken cordon bleu sub. It was good and they even cut it in half for us and plated it for us. We also ordered fries with it to split and they split them for us. So thoughtful! We also asked for cheese sauce for the fries and they split that into two cups as well. The service was wonderful and they had Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives on the TV. We loved that. Will definitely return.

Scotti Martinez
5

We ordered online and picked up our food to eat at home. We were able to choose what we wanted on our subs. Food is amazing!

Michaela Radermacher
4

We ordered 12 garlic Parmesan wings and a large Italian hoagie. The hoagie was super large and tasted pretty good. The wings were a good size and really meaty. The sauce was okay, I think I was expecting a creamy parmeseany peppercorn sauce. None the less, it was all pretty good. The price was mediocre for what we got. About 30.00.

L Bru
5

Super nice gentleman at the counter. The best cheesesteak ever! The bread was beyond amazing and the steak and cheese filling was generous and delicious.

Location

  • PJ's Steak & Hoagie Shack
    PJ's Steak & Hoagie Shack
    114 E Main St, New Holland, PA 17557, United States Hotline: +1 717-351-4949

Nestled in the heart of New Holland, Pennsylvania, PJ's Steak & Hoagie Shack stands out as a beloved local gem for sandwich lovers. This spot is renowned for its generously filled cheesesteaks, which many swear are the best around. The bread alone is a highlight—fresh and perfectly baked, it holds the rich, tender steak and melted cheese with just the right texture and flavor balance.

Beyond the classic cheesesteak, PJ's offers an impressive range of hoagies and subs. The large chicken cordon bleu sub is a definite crowd-pleaser, thoughtfully served with attentive, friendly service that enhances the dining experience. Their fries, crispy and well-seasoned, pair perfectly with house-made sauces that add an extra punch of flavor, showing the kitchen’s commitment to elevating each component of the meal.

Wings here are meaty and satisfying, especially the garlic Parmesan variety, which, while mild, complement the robust sandwiches well. Order customization and online pickup add convenience without sacrificing quality, a testament to PJ’s focus on customer satisfaction.

Overall, PJ’s Steak & Hoagie Shack delivers hearty, no-nonsense fare that feels both comforting and indulgent. It’s a must-visit for anyone craving authentic, flavorful subs and cheesesteaks in a welcoming, down-to-earth setting. The combination of flavorful ingredients, generous portions, and genuine hospitality makes every visit memorable.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Outdoor seating
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards